There is little that makes me more angry than the continue spread of misinformation around the role of vaccinations/immunizations in pediatric health. I once read a quote from an anti-vaccine parent who said something to the effect of "I'm not going to let my child be a guinea pig." I thought to myself, "well, that's fine as long as you know that some other person's kid might die of a totally preventable disease because of your ignorance." I know that is a strong statement, but vaccinations have done so much good, for such a low cost over the last several decades that is disheartening to see some of that undone by misinformation.
On this topic, a friend alerted me to this article in the LATimes. The question discussed there is whether children have a legal right to be vaccinated against preventable diseases, and it is an interesting question. The broader issue of childhood vaccination, however, has to do with the externalities, in this case, positive externalities.
Externalities is economist-speak for any cost or benefit to the production or consumption of a good that does not accrue to the parties (buyers/sellers) involved in the transaction. We most often think of externalities as being negative (pollution or noise from industrial production, for instance), and the implication is that the goods associate with these externalities are over-produced and priced too low. For instance, the consumption of gasoline in automobiles has substantial environmental and other external costs which are not paid by those consuming the gasoline. In this case, the public policy solution is to raise the price of gasoline through a consumption tax so that consumers are made to pay the full cost of their consumption.
Getting back to the issue of vaccination, we can think of vaccination as a good with positive externalities. There are, of course, private benefits to vaccination which accrue to the individuals being vaccinated - that child is less likely to contract the disease for which she is vaccinated. There are also public benefits (the externalities) which accrue to society as the more of us that are vaccinated, the less likely everyone (vaccinated or not) is to contract the disease in question. Unfortunately, when deciding whether or not to vaccinate a child, the parents will surely consider the private benefits, but are less likely to consider or fully account for the public benefits. Let's suppose that parents consider ONLY the private benefits and balance these against the real or perceived private costs of vaccination. The fiduciary costs of vaccination are quite small, but over the last decade or so there has been a strong perception that there are other costs of vaccination including increased risk of the child developing autism or being otherwise adversely affected, despite the fact that these perceptions have been proven to be erroneous by the scientific literature.
We can model this scenario as in the picture above. The blue line represents the private benefits of vaccination which are declining in the number of other people who are vaccinated (since one's probability of contracting the disease, even without being vaccinated, are declining in the number of other people who are vaccinated). The green line represents the private costs of vaccination, be they monetary costs, psychic costs (a fear or needles), or perceived risks. The red line represents the net costs to society of a vaccination which are lower than the private costs because of the benefits which accrue to society. If individuals weigh their private costs against their private benefits, we would expect V people to get vaccinated. But, if we had a benign social planner, she would want V* people to be vaccinated since that is the point at which the social costs of the last vaccination exactly balance the benefits, and this is the heart of the problem: too few people will be vaccinated. In a world where private costs are very low (or the private benefits are very high, even at high societal levels of vaccination) this is not a problem since nearly everyone will choose to be vaccinated. This is the damage that has been done by the anti-vaccination movement - by increasing the perceived private costs, they have widened the gap between perceived private costs and real social costs causing there to be too few children vaccinated, which, in turn, as resulted in outbreaks of diseases many once thought were virtually eradicated in the developed world.
So, we come to the issue of public policy interventions to solve this problem and narrow this vaccination gap. There are a couple of options:
1) Use information campaigns to dispel mis-information and reduce the perceived costs of vaccination - In an ideal world, this solves the problem, but as climate scientists will tell you, information provision only goes so far. The other side of this is to make clear just what the damages of not vaccinating your child could be - make clear the danger in which such parents are putting not only their own child, but those around them.
2) Subsidize vaccination - This would serve to reduce private costs and should encourage more people to vaccinate. But, if perceived costs are very high (fears of autism) this is unlikely to be effective
3) Mandate vaccination - The traditional approach, vaccinations have been mandated for children attending public schools for decades. Basically, this increases the costs of NOT vaccinating one's children since parents would have to home-school or find other educational options for their children to avoid this mandate. Unfortunately, has stopped working as well as it did historically in light of the high perceived risks and we are forced, for now, to deal with
4) Make parents legally liable for vaccination based on the legal right of the child to be vaccinated as suggested in the original LATimes article. To me this would define non-vaccinating parents as "negligent." This is, again, raising the costs of non-vaccination which following Becker's Theory of Crime, should work to mitigate the problem.
Whatever policies we use here (I vote for the kitchen sink approach myself), this map from the Council on Foreign Relations illustrates the problem we are dealing with.
