Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Quebec's Election

I'm no expert on Canadian politics, despite my secondary role at Clarkson as Director of the Center for Canadian Studies, but I do know that yesterday's election results in Quebec are good news for Quebec and Canada.  For 30 or more years, Quebec has flirted with secession from Canada.  When I was a sophomore in college at Duke, working towards my second major in Canadian Studies, I watched the results of the 1995 referendum come in with friends and colleagues in the Canadian Studies house on Campus Drive.  That referendum was painfully close, and famously very geographically split with most of the land area in Quebec voting to leave, but the most populous (by a large margin) area around Montreal voting to stay.

I am convinced that Quebec's separation from Canada would be an economic disaster for Quebec, and, to a lesser extent, Canada as a whole.  Quebec has, for years, been a net beneficiary of Canadian federal spending, which the province would obviously lose with secession.  It would have to fund its own defense forces, and take on many other roles of the federal government, in addition to more strained relations with the rest of Canada, and possibly other trading partners as well.  Capital flight, which has been a problem for Quebec for years (most of Canada's largest banks used to be based in Montreal, but now reside in Toronto) would be greatly exacerbated.


So, back to last night's election:  Quebecers overwhelmingly voted for the Quebec Liberal Party over the separatist Parti Quebecois.  Many interpret this result as a rejection of the idea of Quebec Independence, and the importance, to Quebec's citizens, of economic well-being over an independent Quebec.  This is big news that will, in and of itself, help to secure stronger economic growth for Quebec - firms will no longer have to be concerned about future separation or the associated fallout.  There is no doubt that this will result in a stronger Quebec, and a stronger Canada. Vive le Canada!  

For more on this, see this quick article from the WSJ Canada desk about the results.




Monday, April 7, 2014

I'm heading out west...

...and that has me thinking about an "old" piece of scholarship that I spent a lot of time on in the 2002-2004 period.  My family and I are heading to the Desert Southwest (Zion N.P., Bryce Canyon N.P., and Grand Canyon N.P., all via Las Vegas).  The research, originally intended as my "job market paper" in 2005, was a theoretical analysis of interstate water negotiations.  It was motivated theoretically by this paper by Stefan Ambec and Yves Sprumont and by the book Cadillac Desert, which I have mentioned before, about the history of water in the west.  Following a series of deservedly tough peer reviews, I have let this paper collect dust and chosen to let it sit as an eternal working paper rather than put more time into getting it in condition to be published.

The basic idea was simple - states negotiate compacts (basically interstate treaties) over the distribution of river water between them, and I wanted to know if we could say anything, from an economic theory perspective, about how water was likely to be allocated in this process, and compare this to some theoretical optimum.  Compacts are more common in the western states (the Colorado, for instance) but are becoming more common in the east as well.  When I last revised the paper, in 2011, there were 26 of these interstate agreements:  


So, I went through as much history as I could find about the negotiation processes that led to these compacts, and looked also at situations where negotiations had broken down and court cases had ensued.  I used a bargaining model from Krishna and Serrano (1996), which I felt closely represented the situation faced by the states in these negotiations, and analyzed the situation under the constraints of this particular case (most importantly that water flows downstream and is prohibitively expensive to make flow the other way).

The conclusions?  Not surprisingly, water is not likely to be efficiently allocated through this process (a perfectly competitive market, this is not), and, in particular, that water was likely to be over-allocated to low-value users(states) at the expense of higher value users.  In the case of the Colorado River, this would suggest that more water be allowed to flow to California (the higher value users).

I have always liked this result, and feel that it does add to the conversation, but the reviewers were generally correct that my analysis lacked the rigor needed for journals which publish theoretical economic research, yet was too theoretical for journals interested in water policy!  Hence, its unpublished state.  In any event, as I head out west to see the Colorado River up close, this came to mind, and thought maybe this was the time to let this research see the light of day one more time.

As a tease, here are some of the graphs that came from this work:
and, if you are really interested, shoot me a note at mheintze@clarkson.edu, and I will happily share this paper in its working paper form!  

Friday, April 4, 2014

On the benefits of Connectivity and Trade

For the vast majority of economists, it is a given that trade between [individuals, communities, countries] is good for the well-being of nearly all of the people involved.  There are a number of mechanisms that make this true.  The most often cited is comparative advantage - the result that even if one trading partner is absolutely better at providing every tradeable good, there will still be gains from trade because every partner will have a comparative advantage in at least one good.  That is, if I am "very good" at producing the good of empirical economics research and only "good" at producing the good of theoretical economics research, and I can cooperate with a colleague who is better than me at both of these things, but only a little bit better at empirical research, than we can both benefit by specializing such that I do the empirical work and she does the theory.  In this way, we can increase the total output of our research, which I presume here to be a good thing!  

This result drives most of the discussion amongst economists pushing for opening up trade between countries through free trade agreements and other policies which reduce tariffs, subsidies, and other barriers to the free exchange of goods.  However, there are other reasons why increased trade, and, by extension, connectivity and communication, between societies is good, both for economic growth and overall well-being.  For instance, returns to scale, and agglomeration benefits (benefits that come from have lots of people with similar interests and skills together in one place) can accrue if both people and goods are mobile across borders  One other big advantage that was brought to my attention today is the exchange of ideas and technologies.  From the WSJ via Confessions of a Supply-side Liberal comes this article on fishing technologies in pacific island societies at the time of European contact.  The gist is that societies with larger "effective" populations had more advanced fishing technology than others.  The key word here is "effective" since it doesn't mean just that larger societies did better, but instead that societies with access to larger population/societal networks had this better technology.  Instead of just trading goods between island groups, these groups were exchanging ideas and technology which made them all better off.

This result holds today.  For one illustration of this, look at this NASA image of North Korea at night.  Here is an economically isolated country without access to so many of the technologies available to much of the rest of the world, and its people suffer for it.  An open world is a much more pleasant one than one where we all live in our own little cloisters isolated from the ideas and skills of each other.

Source: http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=83182 (February 24, 2014)

Addendum: Jobs Gone Awry!

Matthew Kahn at UCLA picks up a NYTimes story about a drunken court stenographer and how this has thrown a number of court cases into uncertainty and wonders why we still have human court recorders in this digital age:

"Do unions successfully thwart innovation and the introduction of technology that might reduce the demand for their services? What is the aggregate impact of such self interested efforts for overall U.S productivity and long term growth?

What tasks can people do better than machines? What work is there left for us to do? Do computers write better blog posts?"

How often do we let job considerations get in the way of what is an obvious improvement?