Showing posts with label mathematics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mathematics. Show all posts

Thursday, March 6, 2014

On using Math in the Economics classroom

Two interesting posts recently about math aversion on Miles Kimball's excellent blog. You should read the posts, but the gist is that people are quick to attribute their inability to quickly grasp a subject (in this case, Math) to an innate inability and thus "give up" rather than take the necessary time to learn the material.  I run into this all the time with my students relating to economics itself or the math that is often useful in thinking about economic concepts. Many economics professors will be familiar with what happens in a classroom when the professor mentions calculus (the "C-word). Putting aside those who have a true disability relating to mathematical thinking, I have a couple of thoughts about this issue:

1) One reason why people might jump to the innate inability conclusion is that it "excuses" their struggles. The conclusion means that there is nothing they can do about it, so why try?  This is a truly disabling outcome, but sadly might be justified with some standard economic thinking.  If the marginal cost of effort is high relative to the marginal return, it might pay to write off the whole subject. This is similar to students who, in not studying, thusly excuse their poor performance as not because of their lack of understanding, but because "I didn't study."  This provides them relief since they can then make the internal argument that, "if I study next time, I will do better." As most teachers know, it is the rare student who can truly recover from a bad exam.

2) While the implications of this sort of thinking are pretty clear at the individual level, there are larger implications as well.  If there are enough math-phobic students, professors will eschew mathematical models for rhetorical ones.  As enough professors take this tack and math is not used extensively throughout the curriculum, it no longer pays for students to be required to learn math in the first place, which leads to a vicious cycle which ultimately erodes technical skills from the curriculum.  I'm thinking in particular about business and economics here, where I have observed struggles to maintain calculus, statistics, and other technical subjects in the curriculum.  Of course many of these skills, statistics in particular, will be fundamentally important later in our students' careers, but we are, too often, driven by short term student evaluations which may not reward the teaching of skills that primarily have long-term payoffs.      

3) I have seen lots about mathematics education, although I am no expert, suggesting that students really learn math through application rather than rote memorization. This brings me to one cooperative "solution" to the issue of math in the classroom - we all need, as professors, to use and require mathematical methods in classes where they are relevant so that students can apply what they have learned in their actual mathematics and statistics classes to lots of different topics.  In this way they may actually be able to overcome their math aversion and embrace it!

Lastly, this brings me to reflect on my own expressed inability to learn foreign languages.  I claim to "not be good" at languages, thus excusing me from being able to speak any language besides English.  In my heart, I know that this is false - during a 6-week immersion program in Trois-Rivieres, Quebec, my French improved markedly - but it is an easy way to justify my lack of fluency in comparison to my more practiced colleagues. This podcast from freakonomics covers many of these points in the language context.