Showing posts with label minimum wage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label minimum wage. Show all posts

Friday, January 31, 2014

The Minimum Wage

Chris House from the University of Michigan Economics Department has an excellent post on the impacts of the minimum wage that I think all should read.  Here's the punchline:

"The truth is that, the reason that the minimum wage is politically popular is exactly the same reason that we should be opposed to it. In the best case scenario, while there are no jobs lost, it is not clear that we are transferring from the rich to the poor. It is certain that some low-income households will lose money because of the minimum wage. It is equally certain that some upper-income people will benefit."

He goes on to suggest some alternatives:  

"This is not to say that we should not push for more aggressive income redistribution. The disparity in income inequality has been rising for quite some time and it is completely correct for people to desire a more equitable distribution of income. There are better policies that could be considered however. Expansion of the EITC is often offered as an example of an effective redistributive tool where we have control over who pays and who receives. A negative income tax bracket could transfer income to families in need, and encourage employment of low income workers."

Many others have supported a Guaranteed Basic Income to everyone, which also has attractive features, although it would require substantial changes to systems of taxation (see this analysis in the Canadian context), and, I suspect, is anathema to many Americans.  

With all of that said, the political issues cannot be ignored.  As much as I would like to see a "big fix" to our income inequality issues (along with major tax reform, for instance), that is just not in the offing, politically.  BUT, an increase in the minimum wage may be doable given its political popularity, and that gets to making perfect the enemy of good - by insisting on the perfect policy, do we miss a chance to enact a good policy?  

This same issue comes up in the environmental realm.  Think about fuel economy standards.  Economists are more or less united in thinking that this is the wrong approach to solving transport related environmental issues (gas taxes or more general carbon taxes are much preferred).  But fuel economy standards, in general, pass benefit-cost tests with flying colors.  So, should we rail against such inferior policies when the better policies are politically infeasible?  Probably not, but in backing down, do we foreclose opportunities to do better?  Tough questions.