Thursday, January 16, 2014

In Praise of the Status Quo (or not)

From Moneybox (Matt Yglesias):

"Sixty-one percent of Washingtonians favor sticking with the status quo in which absolutely no buildings over 160 feet tall can be built, the vast majority of the central business district is capped at 130 feet, and the vast majority of the city is capped at a much smaller level than that.

One way of reading this poll, of course, is that Washingtonians have a deep-seated love of suburban sprawl, high tax rates, gentrification and displacement, and a lack of affordable housing. Washingtonians, perhaps, just have a very idiosyncratic view about land-use regulations that leads them to believe that buildings that grace downtown Tulsa, Okla.; Richmond, Va.; and Providence, R.I., are far too enormous for the capital of the mightiest empire the world has ever known. But I think the poll finding that's really interesting is this one—opposition to changing the Height Act cuts across the city's various racial and economic divides but fades substantially among new arrivals to the city."

------------------------------

This is no surprise.  More than anything else, homeowners like land use around their house not to change.  Homeowners oppose wind turbines, power plants, water towers, communications towers, you name it.  But then, after they've been there for 30 years, they oppose removing them!  I recently heard an anecdote about this relating to a naval communications tower near Annapolis that was widely considered an eyesore, but people became accustomed to it.  Part of this is sorting according to preferences (people who like wind turbines are more likely to be the winning bidder on a house near wind turbines), but most of this is just plain aversion to change, and this is critical to the widely despised, but universal, NIMBY effect which is a major hurdle to siting of LULUs (Locally Undesirable Land Uses).  If we are to see significant adoption of renewable resources, this aversion will have to be overcome, in the siting of wind turbines, solar facilities and, most importantly, new transmission lines.      

No comments:

Post a Comment