Over the last few days, besides being installed in a frigid ice rink in the 1000 Islands for a squirt (ages 9-10) hockey tournament, I have seen two opposing columns on the question of whether economic growth is infinite or finite. This is, in fact, an old question, that poses the
Julian Simon thesis of technological optimism against the
Malthusian view that humanity is doomed to over-expand and die. This is a debate I was first exposed to as an undergraduate economics major at
Duke University in a junior-level seminar on Population Economics taught by optimist
Allen C. Kelley.
The issue can best of thought of in the context of a simple equation, the IPAT identity:
Impact=Population x Affluence x Technology
For looking at this broad issue, let Impact represent our collective impact on the world, and assume that there is some physical limit on that impact that we can not exceed, or, alternatively, that if we do, the world as we know it ends, either quickly or over some period of time. Population is obvious, Affluence is represented by GDP/capita (nevermind
arguments about whether GDP is actually a good measure of anything), and Technology represents the impact per unit GDP/capita. That is, the
intensity of our economy with regard to impact on our physical planet.
The original Malthusian story assumed that technology (in particular, our ability to produce food from given land resources) was more or less fixed, but that Population was growing exponentially. I don't think he had anything particular to say about growth in the economy (affluence). Let this run for a few years and we have reached the limit of our ability to feed the population and mass famine ensues. We have avoided global famine, despite his accurate prediction of
population growth:
The key is the unanticipated technological growth which allowed food supply to grow at least as fast as population. We can think of this as a declining intensity, or T, in the IPAT identity. The
first column that I want to link to picks up around here and comes from
Tim Harford (
The Undercover Economist) via the
Freakonomics blog. He argues forcefully that, while Affluence continues to increase globally (the world economy continues to grow) both Population and Technology are or will drive our overall Impact in the opposite direction. That is, as you can see in the image above, most estimates of world population predict decline in population growth so that population eventually levels off or begins to decline. Further, if we look at the intensity of our economies, in the developed world especially, the energy intensity (often the fundamental limit pointed to by pessimists) of our economy has been and almost certainly will continue to decline. That is, we use less and less energy per dollar GDP all the time. So, even if A continues to grow, if P, and especially T, decline fast enough than we can avoid, as a global society, hitting our global carrying capacity.
The
second column comes from
Brian Czech of the
Center for the Advancement of the Steady State Economy and is in
The Huffington Post. CASSE fundamentally believes that further growth in A is unsustainable because they believe that it will be impossible for Technology to keep up. So, if the intensity of our economy will not continue to decrease, than even with a stable population, continued economic growth is unsustainable. In this column, Dr. Czech makes the case that this fundamental truth is so powerful that environmentalists who have focused on climate change are making a grave error and should turn instead to a focus on limiting or eliminating economic growth. This is the polar opposite view from Tim Harford, and encapsulates the pessimistic view on technology.
So, which of these views is the right one? Ultimately I don't think we can know right now because the key factor, how quickly technology will move to increase our global carrying capacity, is unknowable. There have been many civilizations for which Technology was not able to keep up with population and economic growth and which have disappeared (see
Jared Diamond's Collapse), and these examples should concern us. But, the larger history of human civilizations is more positive, and the literature is littered with dire predictions of the limits of human ingenuity and impending collapse (see
The Limits to Growth arguments) that have not come true.
On the walls of
Clarkson University's Concrete Cafe is my favorite quote, from the Roman engineer Julius Frontinus, speaking in the year 10 C.E., "Inventions have long since reached their limit, and I see no hope for further developments." How many of us believe he was right?