Showing posts with label Robert Stavins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Stavins. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

With a price on carbon, renewable portfolio standards are redundant, or worse

Robert Stavins is one of the preeminent environmental economists.  He recently posted a nice, short, piece about why eliminating redundant renewables targets in Europe would be a good thing, both economically and environmentally.  Here is the punchline:

----------------------------
If some emissions reductions are being achieved by the binding renewables policy, then there is less demand overall for tradable allowances. Since the supply of allowances has not changed, this means that allowance prices are inevitably suppressed; and low allowance prices mean less induced climate-friendly technological change over time.
---------------------------

One of the most attractive parts of carbon taxes, in particular, and to a less extent, cap and trade programs is the simplicity, if politicians would learn to keep their hands off of them.  The most recent real chance at a U.S. carbon policy was the Waxman-Markey bill.  When I teach it, late in the semester of my environmental economics class, after my students have heard chapter and verse on the advantages of incentive approaches (and some caveats too), I ask them, when looking through the list of what is included in the bill, "Why do we need a renewable portfolio standard?  Why do we need to mandate building efficiency improvement?"  We don't, is the point, once carbon in priced.