Showing posts with label green GDP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label green GDP. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

On Measures of National Well-Being

Robert Costanza and colleagues have recently published a piece in Nature sounding the death-knell for GDP.  Arguing, again, that GDP is a bad measure of national "success" and pushing for the adoption of other measures to take its place, including the Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI).  There is little or nothing that is new in their criticisms of GDP, and I continue to be frustrated by the discussions.

As has been oft stated, no economist thinks that GDP is a measure of national "success".  It is often misconstrued as such, but I even think that the media is doing a better job of avoiding that mistake recently.  GDP measures the value of the production of marketed goods in an economy.  That's it.  It is only a measure of the economy.  The reason society wants, generally, this number to go up is that more or more valuable production means more money in the economy, no matter how it is distributed, and, generally, more income for individuals.  Costanza and company point to the following issues with GDP: 1) It does not account for degradation of natural resources and the environment;  2) It does not account for income inequality; 3) No accounting (or even positive accounting) for crime and other ills.

1)  This is true.  Depreciation of natural capital is generally not accounted for in GDP, and this does reflect a cost of production.  Many economists have argued strongly that this should be accounted for (see here), and on this point I am in agreement with Costanza et al.  Net National Product (NNP) or Net Domestic Product (NDP) account for depreciation of physical capital, and these are measured, like GDP, by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, but still do not include depreciation of natural capital.  But, it is not so much that we should include this as part of GDP, but that we should measure this depreciation, period, including it in GDP or not.  Of course, there are real challenges to measuring this depreciation and many of the same people who argue against GDP would also oppose the monetization of the environment.

2) President Obama has called income inequality the "defining challenge of our time."  There is little doubt that it is a major issue for a society and it can be measured in various ways, but not in such a way that it could be compared to GDP.  In other words, it is not clear that we can put dollar values on inequality because there is no accepted relationship between how inequality affects the economy or economic growth.  Nor is it clear how individuals or our society as a whole "values" inequality in the way we value goods or even the environment.

3)  GDP does not account for crime, but does account for expenditures on police services or security systems an other preventative measures. Of course, when crime is higher, this will negatively impact other economic activity, implying that it is not actually clear that more crime increases GDP.  But crime definitely affects "well-being" in a negative way, and this gets to what I think is the larger point in the debate about GDP.

What I think Costanza et al. really want is not so much a change in how we measure the economy or well-being, but a change in our societal priorities.  Their criticisms of GDP, I think, fall flat, but really they are critiquing societies apparent prioritization of economic growth over issues of inequality or crime or the environment.  But this is a much larger issue (or, actually, a SERIES of issues) and not something to be fixed by creating some aggregate and subjective measure of well-being like the Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) (which arbitrarily weights a number of societal factors in coming up with a single, blended measure).  I don't see that measuring GDP has caused us to prioritize economic growth.  Instead, we prioritize things like reducing unemployment and increasing standards of living which are usually correlated with economic growth.  Changing these priorities will take much more than adapting measures of well-being.