Showing posts with label pipelines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pipelines. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Addendum to the Environmental Benefits of the KXL Pipeline

The other day I posted about the potential environmental benefits from the KXL Pipeline, mainly keeping oil out of rail cars and off of barges. Our local newspaper, the Watertown Daily Times, has an article today to this effect.

One possible (if expensive) alternative to the pipeline is the St. Lawrence River/Seaway:

"Environmental groups on the U.S. and Canadian sides of the border are keeping an eye on the massive Keystone XL oil pipeline planned from western Canada to the Gulf Coast of Texas: If it is not approved by the U.S. government, the Canadian oil giant that crafted the proposal could decide instead to ship its crude oil east through the St. Lawrence Seaway with ocean freighters, looping around the East Coast to get to Gulf Coast refineries
“Most environmental reviews look at alternatives, and I’m not completely surprised this was discussed because we’ve seen pressure from the Alberta oil field companies trying to get that product to market however they can,” Mr. Willbanks said. “We’ve seen the rail cars being used since they don’t have a pipeline, so it’s not surprising that they would look at the Seaway as an alternative.”

Which would have significant local environmental/ecological impacts in the event of a spill:

Ocean freighters, with capacities of up to 40,000 tons allowed on the Seaway, would pose a major threat of oil spills to the Seaway, Mr. Willbanks said.

“It wouldn’t take but one mistake, and the amount of oil that they can unload would make a significant environmental impact on the river,” he said. “We’re concerned about the difficulty of doing an emergency response and oil spill control in one of the fastest rivers in North America. And we have a tremendous number of bays, estuaries and tributaries that would be almost definitely affected by a spill.”

But there would not likely be local economic benefits:

Such a large-scale operation proposed by TransCanada would greatly increase ship traffic along the Seaway, posing greater danger for oil spills, Mr. Willbanks said. And he doesn’t believe towns and villages situated along the U.S. or Canadian border would see much of an economic benefit, because the majority of Seaway traffic passes through without stopping.

Freighters “don’t really increase economic activity for people on the Canadian or U.S. sides of the river,” he said. “The benefits would go somewhere else. Massena was once hailed as the ‘Detroit of the north country’ — in 1958 that was the promise — but it wasn’t seen. Using the Seaway wouldn’t be a tremendous economic benefit, because the jobs are only going to be at the originating port and terminating port. What you would be seeing is an increase in risks that isn’t balanced by any kind of increase in economic activity.”

So, again, given that the oil is coming out of the ground anyway, the pipeline may be the best transportation option.  

Monday, February 3, 2014

The Environmental Grounds for Approving the Keystone XL Pipeline

Much has been written about the Keystone Pipeline since Friday's release of the State Department's Final Environmental Impact Statement.  The gist of the EIS is that the pipeline is unlikely to significantly affect climate change since the oil is likely to be extracted anyway.  In fact, the report suggests that annual carbon emissions will be higher under status quo alternatives than under KXL.  If you believe that point, then, we can ignore the climate change impacts and move on to the next question, which is, how should this oil be transported to market to minimize other environmental impacts?  The choices seem to be:

  1. Pipeline
  2. Train
  3. Truck
  4. Barge
Given these choices, I feel best about the pipeline option because, while all of these methods are at risk for spills, the pipeline seems the least likely to cause significant environmental or other damage. Pipelines do spill, but these spills occur, mostly, over land.  Of course this causes pollution to soils, and some of that oil would leach into groundwater supplies, including the Ogallala aquifer, and surface water as well.  But, trains and trucks spill too, and when they do, they often spill in populated areas and with explosive (and deadly) consequences (see Lac Megantic, Quebec, for instance).  As to the use of barges, which I was just alerted to today, when these have spills or accidents, there is not just a chance of the oil getting into aquatic ecosystems, but a certainty, and these spills will quickly spread a great distance downstream, as we recently saw in a West Virginia chemical spill (albeit, not from a barge).  

So, what is the best way to transport this oil?  To know for sure, we would need a thorough analysis the risk and damage caused by spills/accidents from each method to understand the environmental costs.  The EIS just released begins this process in section 5.3.  


Table 5.3-1 shows that waterbody crossings and the proximity to populated communities are much higher under status quo alternatives than KXL alternatives.  

Similarly, Table 5.3-3 suggests that potential releases (spill volumes) would be orders of magnitude higher under status quo alternatives relative to KXL.   Finally, what about human safety:


So, this data strongly suggests to me that my instincts are correct and that pipelines will do less harm to humans and the environment than other modes of transport, given that the oil sands are going to be developed, no matter what, and that seems the best assumption (see this Council on Foreign Relations post by Michael Levi who makes this point strongly).  I think it is time for KXL to be approved, and on environmental grounds.  

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Links for 1/16/2014

Some links that caught my eye today:

On the Future of the Economics Blogosphere (Confessions of a Supply Side Liberal) - The view of economics blogging from a high profile macroeconomist.  Timed conveniently with the launch of this blog.

One of the Oddest Bonner Bridge Arguments Yet (Environmental Economics) - Should well-paid environmental lawyers be able to push for policies that might harm lower paid people?  Uh....Yes.

On Zoning, Everyone Likes the Status Quo (MoneyBox) - More on this soon...

Canada Wants an Answer on Keystone XL (WSJ Canada Real Time)