Showing posts with label water. Show all posts
Showing posts with label water. Show all posts

Monday, April 7, 2014

I'm heading out west...

...and that has me thinking about an "old" piece of scholarship that I spent a lot of time on in the 2002-2004 period.  My family and I are heading to the Desert Southwest (Zion N.P., Bryce Canyon N.P., and Grand Canyon N.P., all via Las Vegas).  The research, originally intended as my "job market paper" in 2005, was a theoretical analysis of interstate water negotiations.  It was motivated theoretically by this paper by Stefan Ambec and Yves Sprumont and by the book Cadillac Desert, which I have mentioned before, about the history of water in the west.  Following a series of deservedly tough peer reviews, I have let this paper collect dust and chosen to let it sit as an eternal working paper rather than put more time into getting it in condition to be published.

The basic idea was simple - states negotiate compacts (basically interstate treaties) over the distribution of river water between them, and I wanted to know if we could say anything, from an economic theory perspective, about how water was likely to be allocated in this process, and compare this to some theoretical optimum.  Compacts are more common in the western states (the Colorado, for instance) but are becoming more common in the east as well.  When I last revised the paper, in 2011, there were 26 of these interstate agreements:  


So, I went through as much history as I could find about the negotiation processes that led to these compacts, and looked also at situations where negotiations had broken down and court cases had ensued.  I used a bargaining model from Krishna and Serrano (1996), which I felt closely represented the situation faced by the states in these negotiations, and analyzed the situation under the constraints of this particular case (most importantly that water flows downstream and is prohibitively expensive to make flow the other way).

The conclusions?  Not surprisingly, water is not likely to be efficiently allocated through this process (a perfectly competitive market, this is not), and, in particular, that water was likely to be over-allocated to low-value users(states) at the expense of higher value users.  In the case of the Colorado River, this would suggest that more water be allowed to flow to California (the higher value users).

I have always liked this result, and feel that it does add to the conversation, but the reviewers were generally correct that my analysis lacked the rigor needed for journals which publish theoretical economic research, yet was too theoretical for journals interested in water policy!  Hence, its unpublished state.  In any event, as I head out west to see the Colorado River up close, this came to mind, and thought maybe this was the time to let this research see the light of day one more time.

As a tease, here are some of the graphs that came from this work:
and, if you are really interested, shoot me a note at mheintze@clarkson.edu, and I will happily share this paper in its working paper form!  

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

California's Drought and the Efficiency of Prices to Help Solve it!

I've seen a number of articles recently about California's drought, and the responses by policymakers to deal with it.  A sampling, before I make my main point:


  1. From Eric Biber at Legal Planet on a proposal to override environmental regulations that protect river ecosystems
  2. A graphic via Aguanomics: 
  3. This piece explaining some of the history and background of "hydropolitics" in California, which inspired the above graphic (h/t Aguanomics)
  4. This NYTimes Op/Ed on water in the Central Valley and the produce we depend on which depends on that water (h/t Matthew Kahn at Environmental and Urban Economics)
The fundamental problem with water in a water-scarce world is that it is mis-priced.  Contrary to the classic diamond/water paradox, water is cheap not because it is plentiful (which it is decidedly not in the U.S. West) but because it has been provided by the government through reclamation projects and is thus paid for by U.S. taxpayers rather than by users.  These users are not just household consumers who over-water their unnatural desert lawns, and not just golf courses watering their unnatural greens (which I have a REAL problem with) but farmers.  In fact, easily the largest group of water users in the west are farmers.  None of these users pay rational prices which encourage conservation.  Even in a drought most locations simply call on consumers to water their lawns at night, or take shorter showers, but there is nary a mention of increasing the price paid by consumers.  Because of this we have farmers taking advantage of otherwise advantageous growing conditions (lots of sun, and lots of warmth) in the desert southwest to grow produce that just doesn't belong in a desert.  My favorite is the cotton growing, a notoriously thirsty crop) that takes place in Arizona thanks to the Central Arizona Project, which movers water up out of the Colorado River, over mountains, and in to Central Arizona.   

I am not making a new argument here (the aguanomics blog is founded on it), but one that has been made for decades by economists in all sorts of contexts.  A central tenet of economics is that prices help to allocate goods efficiently between producers and consumers of goods when markets are "perfectly competitive." While the textbook perfect markets rarely/never actually exist, in the case of water we have actively prevented markets from existing, and that is getting in the way of rational water decision-making.  What would higher prices do?

  1. Farmers, seeing water get more expensive, will move to less water intensive techniques, and less water-intensive crops.  This, in turn, will raise the prices of water-intensive crops grown out of season in water scarce areas, like Strawberries.  This, will encourage consumers to shift to more local, in-season food consumption, which has lots of environmental benefits.
  2. Residential consumers will reduce lawn-watering, perhaps shifting to natural desert (or xeric) landscaping.  They will demand more water efficient appliances, encouraging entrepreneurs to develop these same. 
  3. Desert golf courses will, one can hope, go out of business (sorry, golfers!)
  4. Residents of water scarce regions, will, on the margin, start moving away from these regions!  I'm thinking of you, Las Vegas.  
All of these actions will reduce the quantity of water demanded.  Prices work on every margin, as economists say.

I could go on and on about this issue (my students may find this rant familiar), but instead I refer you to one of my favorite books which does a beautiful job of covering the history of water in the U.S. West - Cadillac Desert.  I'll also post my favorite picture from that book which shows subsidence of groundwater use (a related issue, obviously) in California:  

(Photo: Dick Ireland / USGS)