Showing posts with label green jobs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label green jobs. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

The Quest for Jobs Gone Awry, Part II

Nearly a month ago I wrote my most popular post to date about the problems with public policy that focuses so intently on jobs even when jobs are not the proximate motivating factor for the policy under discussion. At that point I promised a second post on the topic of jobs, focusing on jobs in the electricity sector, green, brown, or otherwise, and here I am to deliver on my promise.

The motivating articles for this post are here and here.  Both articles are about energy projects with positive environmental impacts and parochial arguments against them based, in part, on arbitrary state boundaries. The first is about a HUGE (3000 MW) wind power development in Wyoming that would sell its electricity, not in Wyoming, but in California.  This project, if successful, would be a major step towards greening electricity consumption in California and seemingly overcomes one of the biggest hurdles to green power development - geography.  This map from NREL and AWS Truepower makes one thing clear - the areas of this country most ripe for wind development are isolated from the areas of this country with most of the people!  So, this project brings the windpower from its source to where the people are (California).


Surprise, surprise, what do (some) Californians think of this?  That it is terrible because all of those green jobs (wind power doesn't create that many anyway, but that is the subject for yet another blog post) will be in Wyoming and not California!

The second article is about the Champlain Hudson Power Express which is a proposed transmission superhighway running from Quebec to New York City.  This will allow New York to buy cheap and relatively clean hydro power from Northern Quebec.  Not surprisingly, New York power generators and unions are opposed because of the impact on jobs in NYS.  In particular, the negative effect this will have on coal, oil, and nuclear power plants in the state.

But neither of these projects is about jobs!  Both are, instead, about the production and marketability of green power, so let's judge them on those grounds rather than on the basis of the number of jobs created or destroyed.  The Wyoming wind project can have only positive environmental effects (although whether or not subsidies to support such projects pay off is a trickier question), at least as far as climate change and air pollution are concerned.

The environmental effects from the CHPE are a little trickier to think about, but it is my belief that they are substantial.  First and foremost, if the unions are correct and this will allow some shifting away from coal and other fossil fuels, that has obvious air pollution benefits especially for the residents of New York and New England, in addition to climate change benefits.  Secondly, there is substantial potential for wind and other renewable development in Northern New York which is presently constrained by a lack of transmission capacity.  Assuming that these potential projects will be able to hook into the CHPE, that will further the transition for New York away from fossil fuels, and those projects, as much as I don't care about this, will be "in state."  

The last, non-environmental benefit from both of these projects, presumably, is lower electricity costs for consumers.  If, as both proponents and opponents assume, these projects will be able to compete in electricity markets, they must be providing power cheaper than their competitors.  In the case of the Wyoming wind project, this must be a cheaper way to meet California's Renewable Portfolio Standard (which mandates the proportion of electricity consumed in the state that must come from renewable sources). These economic benefits augment the environmental benefits and make my informal benefit cost analysis quite clear. Regardless of the in-state job implications, these projects are good for the states for which they are designed.  Let's try to look beyond jobs and towards the greater good.  


Wednesday, March 5, 2014

The quest for Jobs gone awry

One has trouble reading or listening or watching (does anyone "watch" news anymore?) the news for more than a few minutes without coming across an item about jobs.  Of course this isn't a surprise in our current economy where the labor force continues to shrink and, in many regions, those old standby manufacturing jobs seem to have gone away with little hope of coming back.  The focus on jobs has become so pervasive, in fact, that it is hard to have a discussion of any policy, be it environmental, health and safety, the military, you name it, without discussing the number of jobs it will create or destroy (I love that word in the jobs context - nothing like a little hyperbole to lend sanity to a policy debate).  Because I know more about environmental policies than others, I'll discuss those here, although I believe many of the arguments can be generalized.

There are a number of problems with this focus on jobs:

1) Environmental policy shouldn't be used as employment/economic policy.  That is, we shouldn't judge an environmental policy by how many jobs it creates. Despite what politicians will have you believe, there are tradeoffs, and much of environmental economics is about measuring those tradeoffs so that we are implementing policies for which the benefits exceed the costs.  Importantly, I am admitting here that environmental policies have costs, but this should be no surprise.  This doesn't mean, however, that they shouldn't be implemented - provided the costs are exceeded by the benefits, in terms of human health, ecosystem services, recreational benefits, what have you. Similarly, economic policies focused on creating economic growth may have environmental costs, and these might also still be efficient provided that the economic benefits exceed the environmental costs.  Politicians have a pathological fear of admitting that the policies they support are not win-win-win, and, unfortunately, this is not realistic.

2) For many policies or projects (think Keystone XL) jobs are COSTS, not benefits.  That's right, jobs are bad.  My favorite metaphor for this comes from an article by Andrew Leach:  

"As more potential projects surface, they can always count on the support of ‘job-creating’ politicians, even if the economics are dubious. How about this one, which promises to offer many times the employment and economic impacts of pipeline or rail transportation (millions of jobs are on the line!). Plant your tongue firmly in your cheek, and watch TransPortImpact’s Oil Bucket Brigade ** project sail through the regulatory process. If you haven’t heard about TransPortImpact’s Oil Bucket Brigade project yet, I'm sure you will. After all, it'll likely be looking to hire you."     

The more jobs something creates to do a given job, the more expensive that something will be!  So, we shouldn't be looking to maximize the number of jobs to move oil or generate electricity or make cars! 

3) The smaller the scale of the discussion (the more local), the more dangerous this focus on jobs will be. Specifically what I'm referring to is the race to the bottom that local municipalities, cities, and states compete in to attract companies to relocate. Of course firms are looking to locate in the places that are most profitable for them, so if one place offers a tax benefit, that place will be more attractive than others.  Unfortunately, there are a lot of places in the world, and so this market is competitive, and this competition will drive locations to offer more and more to companies until the net benefits to the location are close to zero.  I'm thinking here of situations like with Alcoa Aluminum in Massena, NY which gets on the order of $148,000 per year PER JOB in discounted electricity prices from New York State. At the macro scale, why do we as a society even care where these companies locate?  The answer is that people are not perfectly mobile, and have a preference to stay in the place they grew up, or currently live and this is perfectly valid.  But, how much should society be willing to pay in order to allow an individual to remain employed in his current location?  Another terrible example of this is when locations which are very close to one another compete, and I am thinking of Saranac Lake and Lake Placid, NY - two towns which are 10 miles apart.  In 2012, Saranac Lake recruited biotech company Myriad RBM to move its Lake Placid facility to Saranac Lake. This seems a terrible waste.   

I have more to say on this topic, but am running out of space for one post.  My next post will focus on jobs in the electricity sector, green and otherwise...