Showing posts with label wind power. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wind power. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

The Quest for Jobs Gone Awry, Part II

Nearly a month ago I wrote my most popular post to date about the problems with public policy that focuses so intently on jobs even when jobs are not the proximate motivating factor for the policy under discussion. At that point I promised a second post on the topic of jobs, focusing on jobs in the electricity sector, green, brown, or otherwise, and here I am to deliver on my promise.

The motivating articles for this post are here and here.  Both articles are about energy projects with positive environmental impacts and parochial arguments against them based, in part, on arbitrary state boundaries. The first is about a HUGE (3000 MW) wind power development in Wyoming that would sell its electricity, not in Wyoming, but in California.  This project, if successful, would be a major step towards greening electricity consumption in California and seemingly overcomes one of the biggest hurdles to green power development - geography.  This map from NREL and AWS Truepower makes one thing clear - the areas of this country most ripe for wind development are isolated from the areas of this country with most of the people!  So, this project brings the windpower from its source to where the people are (California).


Surprise, surprise, what do (some) Californians think of this?  That it is terrible because all of those green jobs (wind power doesn't create that many anyway, but that is the subject for yet another blog post) will be in Wyoming and not California!

The second article is about the Champlain Hudson Power Express which is a proposed transmission superhighway running from Quebec to New York City.  This will allow New York to buy cheap and relatively clean hydro power from Northern Quebec.  Not surprisingly, New York power generators and unions are opposed because of the impact on jobs in NYS.  In particular, the negative effect this will have on coal, oil, and nuclear power plants in the state.

But neither of these projects is about jobs!  Both are, instead, about the production and marketability of green power, so let's judge them on those grounds rather than on the basis of the number of jobs created or destroyed.  The Wyoming wind project can have only positive environmental effects (although whether or not subsidies to support such projects pay off is a trickier question), at least as far as climate change and air pollution are concerned.

The environmental effects from the CHPE are a little trickier to think about, but it is my belief that they are substantial.  First and foremost, if the unions are correct and this will allow some shifting away from coal and other fossil fuels, that has obvious air pollution benefits especially for the residents of New York and New England, in addition to climate change benefits.  Secondly, there is substantial potential for wind and other renewable development in Northern New York which is presently constrained by a lack of transmission capacity.  Assuming that these potential projects will be able to hook into the CHPE, that will further the transition for New York away from fossil fuels, and those projects, as much as I don't care about this, will be "in state."  

The last, non-environmental benefit from both of these projects, presumably, is lower electricity costs for consumers.  If, as both proponents and opponents assume, these projects will be able to compete in electricity markets, they must be providing power cheaper than their competitors.  In the case of the Wyoming wind project, this must be a cheaper way to meet California's Renewable Portfolio Standard (which mandates the proportion of electricity consumed in the state that must come from renewable sources). These economic benefits augment the environmental benefits and make my informal benefit cost analysis quite clear. Regardless of the in-state job implications, these projects are good for the states for which they are designed.  Let's try to look beyond jobs and towards the greater good.