Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Two articles on Energy, Poverty, Development, and Climate Change

I haven't blogged in months as my research agenda and conference (as well as family) travel took over my schedule.  Now I'm preparing to start teaching again in a short two weeks!  However, I want to transition back into more consistent blogging and today I saw two articles which dovetail nicely on energy poverty, electrification, climate change, and economic development.

The first, by Catherine Wolfram at the Energy Institute at UC-Berkeley, discusses some puzzles of rural electrification in the development world.  She points to her own research which suggests that it would often be cheaper to connect the poor to the electricity grid than to invest in solar or other distributed energy systems.  Many of the poor and unconnected are not far from the grid!  This then leads to a conundrum that bringing electricity to the poor will help development but hurt the climate.

This is where the second article, by Lynne Kiesling at Knowledge Problem picks up, and really focuses on the poverty/climate nexus and what rights are held by the poor in a climate change policy regime.

I don't have much to add to this debate, except to say that these are issues that keep my up at night.  I once heard Hadi Dowlatabadi, who has spent much of his distinguished career thinking about climate change, at a conference say that, in fact, poverty is the real issue, not climate change.  It was moving and has kept me thinking every since.

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Quebec's Election

I'm no expert on Canadian politics, despite my secondary role at Clarkson as Director of the Center for Canadian Studies, but I do know that yesterday's election results in Quebec are good news for Quebec and Canada.  For 30 or more years, Quebec has flirted with secession from Canada.  When I was a sophomore in college at Duke, working towards my second major in Canadian Studies, I watched the results of the 1995 referendum come in with friends and colleagues in the Canadian Studies house on Campus Drive.  That referendum was painfully close, and famously very geographically split with most of the land area in Quebec voting to leave, but the most populous (by a large margin) area around Montreal voting to stay.

I am convinced that Quebec's separation from Canada would be an economic disaster for Quebec, and, to a lesser extent, Canada as a whole.  Quebec has, for years, been a net beneficiary of Canadian federal spending, which the province would obviously lose with secession.  It would have to fund its own defense forces, and take on many other roles of the federal government, in addition to more strained relations with the rest of Canada, and possibly other trading partners as well.  Capital flight, which has been a problem for Quebec for years (most of Canada's largest banks used to be based in Montreal, but now reside in Toronto) would be greatly exacerbated.


So, back to last night's election:  Quebecers overwhelmingly voted for the Quebec Liberal Party over the separatist Parti Quebecois.  Many interpret this result as a rejection of the idea of Quebec Independence, and the importance, to Quebec's citizens, of economic well-being over an independent Quebec.  This is big news that will, in and of itself, help to secure stronger economic growth for Quebec - firms will no longer have to be concerned about future separation or the associated fallout.  There is no doubt that this will result in a stronger Quebec, and a stronger Canada. Vive le Canada!  

For more on this, see this quick article from the WSJ Canada desk about the results.




Monday, April 7, 2014

I'm heading out west...

...and that has me thinking about an "old" piece of scholarship that I spent a lot of time on in the 2002-2004 period.  My family and I are heading to the Desert Southwest (Zion N.P., Bryce Canyon N.P., and Grand Canyon N.P., all via Las Vegas).  The research, originally intended as my "job market paper" in 2005, was a theoretical analysis of interstate water negotiations.  It was motivated theoretically by this paper by Stefan Ambec and Yves Sprumont and by the book Cadillac Desert, which I have mentioned before, about the history of water in the west.  Following a series of deservedly tough peer reviews, I have let this paper collect dust and chosen to let it sit as an eternal working paper rather than put more time into getting it in condition to be published.

The basic idea was simple - states negotiate compacts (basically interstate treaties) over the distribution of river water between them, and I wanted to know if we could say anything, from an economic theory perspective, about how water was likely to be allocated in this process, and compare this to some theoretical optimum.  Compacts are more common in the western states (the Colorado, for instance) but are becoming more common in the east as well.  When I last revised the paper, in 2011, there were 26 of these interstate agreements:  


So, I went through as much history as I could find about the negotiation processes that led to these compacts, and looked also at situations where negotiations had broken down and court cases had ensued.  I used a bargaining model from Krishna and Serrano (1996), which I felt closely represented the situation faced by the states in these negotiations, and analyzed the situation under the constraints of this particular case (most importantly that water flows downstream and is prohibitively expensive to make flow the other way).

The conclusions?  Not surprisingly, water is not likely to be efficiently allocated through this process (a perfectly competitive market, this is not), and, in particular, that water was likely to be over-allocated to low-value users(states) at the expense of higher value users.  In the case of the Colorado River, this would suggest that more water be allowed to flow to California (the higher value users).

I have always liked this result, and feel that it does add to the conversation, but the reviewers were generally correct that my analysis lacked the rigor needed for journals which publish theoretical economic research, yet was too theoretical for journals interested in water policy!  Hence, its unpublished state.  In any event, as I head out west to see the Colorado River up close, this came to mind, and thought maybe this was the time to let this research see the light of day one more time.

As a tease, here are some of the graphs that came from this work:
and, if you are really interested, shoot me a note at mheintze@clarkson.edu, and I will happily share this paper in its working paper form!  

Friday, April 4, 2014

On the benefits of Connectivity and Trade

For the vast majority of economists, it is a given that trade between [individuals, communities, countries] is good for the well-being of nearly all of the people involved.  There are a number of mechanisms that make this true.  The most often cited is comparative advantage - the result that even if one trading partner is absolutely better at providing every tradeable good, there will still be gains from trade because every partner will have a comparative advantage in at least one good.  That is, if I am "very good" at producing the good of empirical economics research and only "good" at producing the good of theoretical economics research, and I can cooperate with a colleague who is better than me at both of these things, but only a little bit better at empirical research, than we can both benefit by specializing such that I do the empirical work and she does the theory.  In this way, we can increase the total output of our research, which I presume here to be a good thing!  

This result drives most of the discussion amongst economists pushing for opening up trade between countries through free trade agreements and other policies which reduce tariffs, subsidies, and other barriers to the free exchange of goods.  However, there are other reasons why increased trade, and, by extension, connectivity and communication, between societies is good, both for economic growth and overall well-being.  For instance, returns to scale, and agglomeration benefits (benefits that come from have lots of people with similar interests and skills together in one place) can accrue if both people and goods are mobile across borders  One other big advantage that was brought to my attention today is the exchange of ideas and technologies.  From the WSJ via Confessions of a Supply-side Liberal comes this article on fishing technologies in pacific island societies at the time of European contact.  The gist is that societies with larger "effective" populations had more advanced fishing technology than others.  The key word here is "effective" since it doesn't mean just that larger societies did better, but instead that societies with access to larger population/societal networks had this better technology.  Instead of just trading goods between island groups, these groups were exchanging ideas and technology which made them all better off.

This result holds today.  For one illustration of this, look at this NASA image of North Korea at night.  Here is an economically isolated country without access to so many of the technologies available to much of the rest of the world, and its people suffer for it.  An open world is a much more pleasant one than one where we all live in our own little cloisters isolated from the ideas and skills of each other.

Source: http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=83182 (February 24, 2014)

Addendum: Jobs Gone Awry!

Matthew Kahn at UCLA picks up a NYTimes story about a drunken court stenographer and how this has thrown a number of court cases into uncertainty and wonders why we still have human court recorders in this digital age:

"Do unions successfully thwart innovation and the introduction of technology that might reduce the demand for their services? What is the aggregate impact of such self interested efforts for overall U.S productivity and long term growth?

What tasks can people do better than machines? What work is there left for us to do? Do computers write better blog posts?"

How often do we let job considerations get in the way of what is an obvious improvement?  


Tuesday, March 25, 2014

The Quest for Jobs Gone Awry, Part II

Nearly a month ago I wrote my most popular post to date about the problems with public policy that focuses so intently on jobs even when jobs are not the proximate motivating factor for the policy under discussion. At that point I promised a second post on the topic of jobs, focusing on jobs in the electricity sector, green, brown, or otherwise, and here I am to deliver on my promise.

The motivating articles for this post are here and here.  Both articles are about energy projects with positive environmental impacts and parochial arguments against them based, in part, on arbitrary state boundaries. The first is about a HUGE (3000 MW) wind power development in Wyoming that would sell its electricity, not in Wyoming, but in California.  This project, if successful, would be a major step towards greening electricity consumption in California and seemingly overcomes one of the biggest hurdles to green power development - geography.  This map from NREL and AWS Truepower makes one thing clear - the areas of this country most ripe for wind development are isolated from the areas of this country with most of the people!  So, this project brings the windpower from its source to where the people are (California).


Surprise, surprise, what do (some) Californians think of this?  That it is terrible because all of those green jobs (wind power doesn't create that many anyway, but that is the subject for yet another blog post) will be in Wyoming and not California!

The second article is about the Champlain Hudson Power Express which is a proposed transmission superhighway running from Quebec to New York City.  This will allow New York to buy cheap and relatively clean hydro power from Northern Quebec.  Not surprisingly, New York power generators and unions are opposed because of the impact on jobs in NYS.  In particular, the negative effect this will have on coal, oil, and nuclear power plants in the state.

But neither of these projects is about jobs!  Both are, instead, about the production and marketability of green power, so let's judge them on those grounds rather than on the basis of the number of jobs created or destroyed.  The Wyoming wind project can have only positive environmental effects (although whether or not subsidies to support such projects pay off is a trickier question), at least as far as climate change and air pollution are concerned.

The environmental effects from the CHPE are a little trickier to think about, but it is my belief that they are substantial.  First and foremost, if the unions are correct and this will allow some shifting away from coal and other fossil fuels, that has obvious air pollution benefits especially for the residents of New York and New England, in addition to climate change benefits.  Secondly, there is substantial potential for wind and other renewable development in Northern New York which is presently constrained by a lack of transmission capacity.  Assuming that these potential projects will be able to hook into the CHPE, that will further the transition for New York away from fossil fuels, and those projects, as much as I don't care about this, will be "in state."  

The last, non-environmental benefit from both of these projects, presumably, is lower electricity costs for consumers.  If, as both proponents and opponents assume, these projects will be able to compete in electricity markets, they must be providing power cheaper than their competitors.  In the case of the Wyoming wind project, this must be a cheaper way to meet California's Renewable Portfolio Standard (which mandates the proportion of electricity consumed in the state that must come from renewable sources). These economic benefits augment the environmental benefits and make my informal benefit cost analysis quite clear. Regardless of the in-state job implications, these projects are good for the states for which they are designed.  Let's try to look beyond jobs and towards the greater good.  


The Challenge of Immunizations

There is little that makes me more angry than the continue spread of misinformation around the role of vaccinations/immunizations in pediatric health.  I once read a quote from an anti-vaccine parent who said something to the effect of "I'm not going to let my child be a guinea pig." I thought to myself, "well, that's fine as long as you know that some other person's kid might die of a totally preventable disease because of your ignorance."  I know that is a strong statement, but vaccinations have done so much good, for such a low cost over the last several decades that is disheartening to see some of that undone by misinformation.  

On this topic, a friend alerted me to this article in the LATimes.  The question discussed there is whether children have a legal right to be vaccinated against preventable diseases, and it is an interesting question.  The broader issue of childhood vaccination, however, has to do with the externalities, in this case, positive externalities.

Externalities is economist-speak for any cost or benefit to the production or consumption of a good that does not accrue to the parties (buyers/sellers) involved in the transaction.  We most often think of externalities as being negative (pollution or noise from industrial production, for instance), and the implication is that the goods associate with these externalities are over-produced and priced too low.  For instance, the consumption of gasoline in automobiles has substantial environmental and other external costs which are not paid by those consuming the gasoline.  In this case, the public policy solution is to raise the price of gasoline through a consumption tax so that consumers are made to pay the full cost of their consumption.

Getting back to the issue of vaccination, we can think of vaccination as a good with positive externalities. There are, of course, private benefits to vaccination which accrue to the individuals being vaccinated - that child is less likely to contract the disease for which she is vaccinated.  There are also public benefits (the externalities) which accrue to society as the more of us that are vaccinated, the less likely everyone (vaccinated or not) is to contract the disease in question. Unfortunately, when deciding whether or not to vaccinate a child, the parents will surely consider the private benefits, but are less likely to consider or fully account for the public benefits.  Let's suppose that parents consider ONLY the private benefits and balance these against the real or perceived private costs of vaccination.  The fiduciary costs of vaccination are quite small, but over the last decade or so there has been a strong perception that there are other costs of vaccination including increased risk of the child developing autism or being otherwise adversely affected, despite the fact that these perceptions have been proven to be erroneous by the scientific literature.


We can model this scenario as in the picture above.  The blue line represents the private benefits of vaccination which are declining in the number of other people who are vaccinated (since one's probability of contracting the disease, even without being vaccinated, are declining in the number of other people who are vaccinated).  The green line represents the private costs of vaccination, be they monetary costs, psychic costs (a fear or needles), or perceived risks.  The red line represents the net costs to society of a vaccination which are lower than the private costs because of the benefits which accrue to society.  If individuals weigh their private costs against their private benefits, we would expect V people to get vaccinated.  But, if we had a benign social planner, she would want V* people to be vaccinated since that is the point at which the social costs of the last vaccination exactly balance the benefits, and this is the heart of the problem:  too few people will be vaccinated.  In a world where private costs are very low (or the private benefits are very high, even at high societal levels of vaccination) this is not a problem since nearly everyone will choose to be vaccinated. This is the damage that has been done by the anti-vaccination movement - by increasing the perceived private costs, they have widened the gap between perceived private costs and real social costs causing there to be too few children vaccinated, which, in turn, as resulted in outbreaks of diseases many once thought were virtually eradicated in the developed world.

So, we come to the issue of public policy interventions to solve this problem and narrow this vaccination gap. There are a couple of options:

1) Use information campaigns to dispel mis-information and reduce the perceived costs of vaccination - In an ideal world, this solves the problem, but as climate scientists will tell you, information provision only goes so far. The other side of this is to make clear just what the damages of not vaccinating your child could be - make clear the danger in which such parents are putting not only their own child, but those around them.

2) Subsidize vaccination - This would serve to reduce private costs and should encourage more people to vaccinate.  But, if perceived costs are very high (fears of autism) this is unlikely to be effective

3) Mandate vaccination - The traditional approach, vaccinations have been mandated for children attending public schools for decades.  Basically, this increases the costs of NOT vaccinating one's children since parents would have to home-school or find other educational options for their children to avoid this mandate. Unfortunately, has stopped working as well as it did historically in light of the high perceived risks and we are forced, for now, to deal with

4) Make parents legally liable for vaccination based on the legal right of the child to be vaccinated as suggested in the original LATimes article.  To me this would define non-vaccinating parents as "negligent." This is, again, raising the costs of non-vaccination which following Becker's Theory of Crime, should work to mitigate the problem.

Whatever policies we use here (I vote for the kitchen sink approach myself), this map from the Council on Foreign Relations illustrates the problem we are dealing with.

Thursday, March 6, 2014

On using Math in the Economics classroom

Two interesting posts recently about math aversion on Miles Kimball's excellent blog. You should read the posts, but the gist is that people are quick to attribute their inability to quickly grasp a subject (in this case, Math) to an innate inability and thus "give up" rather than take the necessary time to learn the material.  I run into this all the time with my students relating to economics itself or the math that is often useful in thinking about economic concepts. Many economics professors will be familiar with what happens in a classroom when the professor mentions calculus (the "C-word). Putting aside those who have a true disability relating to mathematical thinking, I have a couple of thoughts about this issue:

1) One reason why people might jump to the innate inability conclusion is that it "excuses" their struggles. The conclusion means that there is nothing they can do about it, so why try?  This is a truly disabling outcome, but sadly might be justified with some standard economic thinking.  If the marginal cost of effort is high relative to the marginal return, it might pay to write off the whole subject. This is similar to students who, in not studying, thusly excuse their poor performance as not because of their lack of understanding, but because "I didn't study."  This provides them relief since they can then make the internal argument that, "if I study next time, I will do better." As most teachers know, it is the rare student who can truly recover from a bad exam.

2) While the implications of this sort of thinking are pretty clear at the individual level, there are larger implications as well.  If there are enough math-phobic students, professors will eschew mathematical models for rhetorical ones.  As enough professors take this tack and math is not used extensively throughout the curriculum, it no longer pays for students to be required to learn math in the first place, which leads to a vicious cycle which ultimately erodes technical skills from the curriculum.  I'm thinking in particular about business and economics here, where I have observed struggles to maintain calculus, statistics, and other technical subjects in the curriculum.  Of course many of these skills, statistics in particular, will be fundamentally important later in our students' careers, but we are, too often, driven by short term student evaluations which may not reward the teaching of skills that primarily have long-term payoffs.      

3) I have seen lots about mathematics education, although I am no expert, suggesting that students really learn math through application rather than rote memorization. This brings me to one cooperative "solution" to the issue of math in the classroom - we all need, as professors, to use and require mathematical methods in classes where they are relevant so that students can apply what they have learned in their actual mathematics and statistics classes to lots of different topics.  In this way they may actually be able to overcome their math aversion and embrace it!

Lastly, this brings me to reflect on my own expressed inability to learn foreign languages.  I claim to "not be good" at languages, thus excusing me from being able to speak any language besides English.  In my heart, I know that this is false - during a 6-week immersion program in Trois-Rivieres, Quebec, my French improved markedly - but it is an easy way to justify my lack of fluency in comparison to my more practiced colleagues. This podcast from freakonomics covers many of these points in the language context.  

Wednesday, March 5, 2014

What are the economic costs of pollution? (or, what are the economic benefits of pollution reduction?)

Earlier today I discussed the importance of evaluating environmental and economic policies on costs and benefits rather than on jobs gained/lost:

"Environmental policy shouldn't be used as employment/economic policy. That is, we shouldn't judge an environmental policy by how many jobs it creates. Despite what politicians will have you believe, there are tradeoffs, and much of environmental economics is about measuring those tradeoffs so that we are implementing policies for which the benefits exceed the costs. Importantly, I am admitting here that environmental policies have costs, but this should be no surprise. This doesn't mean, however, that they shouldn't be implemented - provided the costs are exceeded by the benefits, in terms of human health, ecosystem services, recreational benefits, what have you. Similarly, economic policies focused on creating economic growth may have environmental costs, and these might also still be efficient provided that the economic benefits exceed the environmental costs. Politicians have a pathological fear of admitting that the policies they support are not win-win-win, and, unfortunately, this is not realistic."

This, from the NBER via Freakonomics is one example of the economic benefits of environmental improvements:  

"Back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest that nationwide reductions in PM2.5 from 1999 to 2008 generated $19.5 billion in labor cost savings, which is roughly one-third of the total welfare benefits associated with this change." (Particulate Pollution and the Productivity of Pear Packers, by Tom Chang, Joshua Graff Zivin, Tal Gross, Matthew Neidell, NBER Working Paper #19944)




The quest for Jobs gone awry

One has trouble reading or listening or watching (does anyone "watch" news anymore?) the news for more than a few minutes without coming across an item about jobs.  Of course this isn't a surprise in our current economy where the labor force continues to shrink and, in many regions, those old standby manufacturing jobs seem to have gone away with little hope of coming back.  The focus on jobs has become so pervasive, in fact, that it is hard to have a discussion of any policy, be it environmental, health and safety, the military, you name it, without discussing the number of jobs it will create or destroy (I love that word in the jobs context - nothing like a little hyperbole to lend sanity to a policy debate).  Because I know more about environmental policies than others, I'll discuss those here, although I believe many of the arguments can be generalized.

There are a number of problems with this focus on jobs:

1) Environmental policy shouldn't be used as employment/economic policy.  That is, we shouldn't judge an environmental policy by how many jobs it creates. Despite what politicians will have you believe, there are tradeoffs, and much of environmental economics is about measuring those tradeoffs so that we are implementing policies for which the benefits exceed the costs.  Importantly, I am admitting here that environmental policies have costs, but this should be no surprise.  This doesn't mean, however, that they shouldn't be implemented - provided the costs are exceeded by the benefits, in terms of human health, ecosystem services, recreational benefits, what have you. Similarly, economic policies focused on creating economic growth may have environmental costs, and these might also still be efficient provided that the economic benefits exceed the environmental costs.  Politicians have a pathological fear of admitting that the policies they support are not win-win-win, and, unfortunately, this is not realistic.

2) For many policies or projects (think Keystone XL) jobs are COSTS, not benefits.  That's right, jobs are bad.  My favorite metaphor for this comes from an article by Andrew Leach:  

"As more potential projects surface, they can always count on the support of ‘job-creating’ politicians, even if the economics are dubious. How about this one, which promises to offer many times the employment and economic impacts of pipeline or rail transportation (millions of jobs are on the line!). Plant your tongue firmly in your cheek, and watch TransPortImpact’s Oil Bucket Brigade ** project sail through the regulatory process. If you haven’t heard about TransPortImpact’s Oil Bucket Brigade project yet, I'm sure you will. After all, it'll likely be looking to hire you."     

The more jobs something creates to do a given job, the more expensive that something will be!  So, we shouldn't be looking to maximize the number of jobs to move oil or generate electricity or make cars! 

3) The smaller the scale of the discussion (the more local), the more dangerous this focus on jobs will be. Specifically what I'm referring to is the race to the bottom that local municipalities, cities, and states compete in to attract companies to relocate. Of course firms are looking to locate in the places that are most profitable for them, so if one place offers a tax benefit, that place will be more attractive than others.  Unfortunately, there are a lot of places in the world, and so this market is competitive, and this competition will drive locations to offer more and more to companies until the net benefits to the location are close to zero.  I'm thinking here of situations like with Alcoa Aluminum in Massena, NY which gets on the order of $148,000 per year PER JOB in discounted electricity prices from New York State. At the macro scale, why do we as a society even care where these companies locate?  The answer is that people are not perfectly mobile, and have a preference to stay in the place they grew up, or currently live and this is perfectly valid.  But, how much should society be willing to pay in order to allow an individual to remain employed in his current location?  Another terrible example of this is when locations which are very close to one another compete, and I am thinking of Saranac Lake and Lake Placid, NY - two towns which are 10 miles apart.  In 2012, Saranac Lake recruited biotech company Myriad RBM to move its Lake Placid facility to Saranac Lake. This seems a terrible waste.   

I have more to say on this topic, but am running out of space for one post.  My next post will focus on jobs in the electricity sector, green and otherwise...

More on GDP as a measure of "well-being"

Back on January 22nd I wrote a post discussing criticisms of GDP in response to Costanza et al's Nature article calling for the "end" of GDP.  In my post, I said:

"No economist thinks that GDP is a measure of national "success".  It is often misconstrued as such, but I even think that the media is doing a better job of avoiding that mistake recently.  GDP measures the value of the production of marketed goods in an economy.  That's it.  It is only a measure of the economy.  The reason society wants, generally, this number to go up is that more or more valuable production means more money in the economy, no matter how it is distributed, and, generally, more income for individuals."

and went on to assert that most criticisms of GDP are actually misplaced calls for a change in societal priorities.

Matt Yglesias recently echoed this discussion with his piece entitled "GDP isn't flawed, it's just not that important."

"When you look at specific cases lots of things that are pleasant don't add to market output and lots of things that do add to market output aren't especially important or meritorious. This isn't a "flaw" in GDP, it's a sign that total market economic output isn't all there is to life."

I recommend you read the whole piece.

UPDATE: I also want to bring your attention to a student blog post at Confessions of a Supply-Side Liberal that updates us on the status of world poverty.  While warning us against any resting on laurels, Jessica Hammer points us to some good news on world poverty - we've made a lot of progress.  

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

California's Drought and the Efficiency of Prices to Help Solve it!

I've seen a number of articles recently about California's drought, and the responses by policymakers to deal with it.  A sampling, before I make my main point:


  1. From Eric Biber at Legal Planet on a proposal to override environmental regulations that protect river ecosystems
  2. A graphic via Aguanomics: 
  3. This piece explaining some of the history and background of "hydropolitics" in California, which inspired the above graphic (h/t Aguanomics)
  4. This NYTimes Op/Ed on water in the Central Valley and the produce we depend on which depends on that water (h/t Matthew Kahn at Environmental and Urban Economics)
The fundamental problem with water in a water-scarce world is that it is mis-priced.  Contrary to the classic diamond/water paradox, water is cheap not because it is plentiful (which it is decidedly not in the U.S. West) but because it has been provided by the government through reclamation projects and is thus paid for by U.S. taxpayers rather than by users.  These users are not just household consumers who over-water their unnatural desert lawns, and not just golf courses watering their unnatural greens (which I have a REAL problem with) but farmers.  In fact, easily the largest group of water users in the west are farmers.  None of these users pay rational prices which encourage conservation.  Even in a drought most locations simply call on consumers to water their lawns at night, or take shorter showers, but there is nary a mention of increasing the price paid by consumers.  Because of this we have farmers taking advantage of otherwise advantageous growing conditions (lots of sun, and lots of warmth) in the desert southwest to grow produce that just doesn't belong in a desert.  My favorite is the cotton growing, a notoriously thirsty crop) that takes place in Arizona thanks to the Central Arizona Project, which movers water up out of the Colorado River, over mountains, and in to Central Arizona.   

I am not making a new argument here (the aguanomics blog is founded on it), but one that has been made for decades by economists in all sorts of contexts.  A central tenet of economics is that prices help to allocate goods efficiently between producers and consumers of goods when markets are "perfectly competitive." While the textbook perfect markets rarely/never actually exist, in the case of water we have actively prevented markets from existing, and that is getting in the way of rational water decision-making.  What would higher prices do?

  1. Farmers, seeing water get more expensive, will move to less water intensive techniques, and less water-intensive crops.  This, in turn, will raise the prices of water-intensive crops grown out of season in water scarce areas, like Strawberries.  This, will encourage consumers to shift to more local, in-season food consumption, which has lots of environmental benefits.
  2. Residential consumers will reduce lawn-watering, perhaps shifting to natural desert (or xeric) landscaping.  They will demand more water efficient appliances, encouraging entrepreneurs to develop these same. 
  3. Desert golf courses will, one can hope, go out of business (sorry, golfers!)
  4. Residents of water scarce regions, will, on the margin, start moving away from these regions!  I'm thinking of you, Las Vegas.  
All of these actions will reduce the quantity of water demanded.  Prices work on every margin, as economists say.

I could go on and on about this issue (my students may find this rant familiar), but instead I refer you to one of my favorite books which does a beautiful job of covering the history of water in the U.S. West - Cadillac Desert.  I'll also post my favorite picture from that book which shows subsidence of groundwater use (a related issue, obviously) in California:  

(Photo: Dick Ireland / USGS)

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Addendum to the Environmental Benefits of the KXL Pipeline

The other day I posted about the potential environmental benefits from the KXL Pipeline, mainly keeping oil out of rail cars and off of barges. Our local newspaper, the Watertown Daily Times, has an article today to this effect.

One possible (if expensive) alternative to the pipeline is the St. Lawrence River/Seaway:

"Environmental groups on the U.S. and Canadian sides of the border are keeping an eye on the massive Keystone XL oil pipeline planned from western Canada to the Gulf Coast of Texas: If it is not approved by the U.S. government, the Canadian oil giant that crafted the proposal could decide instead to ship its crude oil east through the St. Lawrence Seaway with ocean freighters, looping around the East Coast to get to Gulf Coast refineries
“Most environmental reviews look at alternatives, and I’m not completely surprised this was discussed because we’ve seen pressure from the Alberta oil field companies trying to get that product to market however they can,” Mr. Willbanks said. “We’ve seen the rail cars being used since they don’t have a pipeline, so it’s not surprising that they would look at the Seaway as an alternative.”

Which would have significant local environmental/ecological impacts in the event of a spill:

Ocean freighters, with capacities of up to 40,000 tons allowed on the Seaway, would pose a major threat of oil spills to the Seaway, Mr. Willbanks said.

“It wouldn’t take but one mistake, and the amount of oil that they can unload would make a significant environmental impact on the river,” he said. “We’re concerned about the difficulty of doing an emergency response and oil spill control in one of the fastest rivers in North America. And we have a tremendous number of bays, estuaries and tributaries that would be almost definitely affected by a spill.”

But there would not likely be local economic benefits:

Such a large-scale operation proposed by TransCanada would greatly increase ship traffic along the Seaway, posing greater danger for oil spills, Mr. Willbanks said. And he doesn’t believe towns and villages situated along the U.S. or Canadian border would see much of an economic benefit, because the majority of Seaway traffic passes through without stopping.

Freighters “don’t really increase economic activity for people on the Canadian or U.S. sides of the river,” he said. “The benefits would go somewhere else. Massena was once hailed as the ‘Detroit of the north country’ — in 1958 that was the promise — but it wasn’t seen. Using the Seaway wouldn’t be a tremendous economic benefit, because the jobs are only going to be at the originating port and terminating port. What you would be seeing is an increase in risks that isn’t balanced by any kind of increase in economic activity.”

So, again, given that the oil is coming out of the ground anyway, the pipeline may be the best transportation option.  

Monday, February 3, 2014

The Environmental Grounds for Approving the Keystone XL Pipeline

Much has been written about the Keystone Pipeline since Friday's release of the State Department's Final Environmental Impact Statement.  The gist of the EIS is that the pipeline is unlikely to significantly affect climate change since the oil is likely to be extracted anyway.  In fact, the report suggests that annual carbon emissions will be higher under status quo alternatives than under KXL.  If you believe that point, then, we can ignore the climate change impacts and move on to the next question, which is, how should this oil be transported to market to minimize other environmental impacts?  The choices seem to be:

  1. Pipeline
  2. Train
  3. Truck
  4. Barge
Given these choices, I feel best about the pipeline option because, while all of these methods are at risk for spills, the pipeline seems the least likely to cause significant environmental or other damage. Pipelines do spill, but these spills occur, mostly, over land.  Of course this causes pollution to soils, and some of that oil would leach into groundwater supplies, including the Ogallala aquifer, and surface water as well.  But, trains and trucks spill too, and when they do, they often spill in populated areas and with explosive (and deadly) consequences (see Lac Megantic, Quebec, for instance).  As to the use of barges, which I was just alerted to today, when these have spills or accidents, there is not just a chance of the oil getting into aquatic ecosystems, but a certainty, and these spills will quickly spread a great distance downstream, as we recently saw in a West Virginia chemical spill (albeit, not from a barge).  

So, what is the best way to transport this oil?  To know for sure, we would need a thorough analysis the risk and damage caused by spills/accidents from each method to understand the environmental costs.  The EIS just released begins this process in section 5.3.  


Table 5.3-1 shows that waterbody crossings and the proximity to populated communities are much higher under status quo alternatives than KXL alternatives.  

Similarly, Table 5.3-3 suggests that potential releases (spill volumes) would be orders of magnitude higher under status quo alternatives relative to KXL.   Finally, what about human safety:


So, this data strongly suggests to me that my instincts are correct and that pipelines will do less harm to humans and the environment than other modes of transport, given that the oil sands are going to be developed, no matter what, and that seems the best assumption (see this Council on Foreign Relations post by Michael Levi who makes this point strongly).  I think it is time for KXL to be approved, and on environmental grounds.  

Friday, January 31, 2014

The Minimum Wage

Chris House from the University of Michigan Economics Department has an excellent post on the impacts of the minimum wage that I think all should read.  Here's the punchline:

"The truth is that, the reason that the minimum wage is politically popular is exactly the same reason that we should be opposed to it. In the best case scenario, while there are no jobs lost, it is not clear that we are transferring from the rich to the poor. It is certain that some low-income households will lose money because of the minimum wage. It is equally certain that some upper-income people will benefit."

He goes on to suggest some alternatives:  

"This is not to say that we should not push for more aggressive income redistribution. The disparity in income inequality has been rising for quite some time and it is completely correct for people to desire a more equitable distribution of income. There are better policies that could be considered however. Expansion of the EITC is often offered as an example of an effective redistributive tool where we have control over who pays and who receives. A negative income tax bracket could transfer income to families in need, and encourage employment of low income workers."

Many others have supported a Guaranteed Basic Income to everyone, which also has attractive features, although it would require substantial changes to systems of taxation (see this analysis in the Canadian context), and, I suspect, is anathema to many Americans.  

With all of that said, the political issues cannot be ignored.  As much as I would like to see a "big fix" to our income inequality issues (along with major tax reform, for instance), that is just not in the offing, politically.  BUT, an increase in the minimum wage may be doable given its political popularity, and that gets to making perfect the enemy of good - by insisting on the perfect policy, do we miss a chance to enact a good policy?  

This same issue comes up in the environmental realm.  Think about fuel economy standards.  Economists are more or less united in thinking that this is the wrong approach to solving transport related environmental issues (gas taxes or more general carbon taxes are much preferred).  But fuel economy standards, in general, pass benefit-cost tests with flying colors.  So, should we rail against such inferior policies when the better policies are politically infeasible?  Probably not, but in backing down, do we foreclose opportunities to do better?  Tough questions.  

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

On the importance of being wrong

Ran across this piece at npr.org this morning, about what scientific ideas are "ready for retirement," a question posed at Edge.org by John Brockman.  The NPR piece summarizes the responses:

------------------

Responses spanned the sciences, with many questioning aspects of science itself. For example, writer Brian Christian took on current practices in scientific publishing, with others challenging a host of scientific ideals and assumptions: that scientific discovery should be valued over the lives of scientists (Kathryn Clancy), that scientists should stick to science (Buddhini Samarasinghe) and (inversely) that non-scientists can't do science (Kate Mills), that the hallmark of scientific claims is their falsifiability (Sean Carroll) and that there is "a" (singular) scientific method (Melanie Swan).

My own response questioned the reductionist idea that the mind is just the brain, arguing that explanations for behavior and mental states shouldn't be couched in strictly neuroscientific terms. In a related response, Joel Gold and Ian Gold urged that we do away with the idea that mental illness is nothing but brain illness. Instead, we should recognize that "understanding and treating brain disorders sometimes has to move outside the skull."

Our responses were just two of many to focus on psychology and the cognitive sciences. Quite a few essays, for example, took on formulations of nature versus nurture when it comes to human capacities and behaviors, an idea that — according to Timo Hanney — "truly deserves a bullet in the back of its head."

Steven Pinker questioned every term in the "genes + environment = behavior" equation. Alison Gopnik argued that when you take a close look, questions about what's innate can quickly become incoherent:


Of course, for a long time, people have pointed out that nature and nurture must interact for a particular trait to develop. But several recent scientific developments challenge the idea of innate traits in a deeper way. It isn't just that it's a little of both, some mix of nurture and nature, but that the distinction itself is fundamentally misconceived.

But other responses were directed more strongly towards one particular pole of the nature-nurture dichotomy, with Daniel L. Everett urging us to renounce appeals to "instinct" and "innate" knowledge on the one hand and Kiley Hamlin highlighting the dangers of assuming a blank slate when it comes to moral beliefs and behaviors, on the other.

In two independent essays broaching another aspect of cognition, Sarah-Jayne Blakemore andStephen M. Kosslyn urged readers to abandon scientifically-unfounded claims about the left brain versus the right brain, a topic I recently covered here at 13.7.

Other notable contributions about the mind by psychologists included a piece by June Gruberarguing that "negative" emotions aren't always bad and "positive" emotions always good. And one by Tom Griffiths (full disclosure: he's my husband) arguing that bias isn't always a bad thing when it comes to human or artificial intelligence. Then there was a co-authored response bypsychologist Laurie Santos and philosopher Tamar Gendler on the gulf between knowing about cognitive biases and avoiding them. Susan Fiske and Jamil Zaki wrote on human warmth and altruism.
-------------------

However, I, like the author of the piece, was especially attracted to the idea "that in fact, scientific ideas are often useful even when we know them to be false, in part because they foster a certain kind of understanding, or provide a standard against which we can understand a complex system." The author goes on to quote a response from economist Richard Thaler about the "wrong" models or economics:  

"In economics there are certainly many theories, hypotheses and models that are badly flawed descriptions of the behavior of economic agents, so one might think that I would have many nominations for ideas that should be given funerals. But I don't. That is because most of these theories, while demonstrably poor descriptions of reality, are extremely useful as theoretical baselines. As such, it would be a mistake to declare these theories dead... Let's keep these and many other wrong theories and hypotheses alive, but remember they are just hypotheses, not facts. (Richard H. Thaler)"

This response fits well my own relationship with the "rational actor" economic models of human behavior. Strictly speaking all of these models are "wrong" (in the sense of not being fully correct) but they can nonetheless provide important insight into behaviors that, in turn, can help us as a society make policy and other decisions.  I begin my Managerial Economics class each fall by making this point: that, indeed, many of the models I will describe will be simple, and wrong, but still provide important insights to real world behaviors and outcomes.  Just because a theory or model is "wrong" doesn't mean it is not useful.  

Monday, January 27, 2014

Economic Growth: Finite or Infinite?

Over the last few days, besides being installed in a frigid ice rink in the 1000 Islands for a squirt (ages 9-10) hockey tournament, I have seen two opposing columns on the question of whether economic growth is infinite or finite.  This is, in fact, an old question, that poses the Julian Simon thesis of technological optimism against the Malthusian view that humanity is doomed to over-expand and die. This is a debate I was first exposed to as an undergraduate economics major at Duke University in a junior-level seminar on Population Economics taught by optimist Allen C. Kelley.

The issue can best of thought of in the context of a simple equation, the IPAT identity:

Impact=Population x Affluence x Technology

For looking at this broad issue, let Impact represent our collective impact on the world, and assume that there is some physical limit on that impact that we can not exceed, or, alternatively, that if we do, the world as we know it ends, either quickly or over some period of time.  Population is obvious, Affluence is represented by GDP/capita (nevermind arguments about whether GDP is actually a good measure of anything), and Technology represents the impact per unit GDP/capita.  That is, the intensity of our economy with regard to impact on our physical planet.

The original Malthusian story assumed that technology (in particular, our ability to produce food from given land resources) was more or less fixed, but that Population was growing exponentially.  I don't think he had anything particular to say about growth in the economy (affluence).  Let this run for a few years and we have reached the limit of our ability to feed the population and mass famine ensues.  We have avoided global famine, despite his accurate prediction of population growth:



The key is the unanticipated technological growth which allowed food supply to grow at least as fast as population.  We can think of this as a declining intensity, or T, in the IPAT identity.  The first column that I want to link to picks up around here and comes from Tim Harford (The Undercover Economist) via the Freakonomics blog.   He argues forcefully that, while Affluence continues to increase globally (the world economy continues to grow) both Population and Technology are or will drive our overall Impact in the opposite direction.  That is, as you can see in the image above, most estimates of world population predict decline in population growth so that population eventually levels off or begins to decline.  Further, if we look at the intensity of our economies, in the developed world especially, the energy intensity (often the fundamental limit pointed to by pessimists) of our economy has been and almost certainly will continue to decline. That is, we use less and less energy per dollar GDP all the time.  So, even if A continues to grow, if P, and especially T, decline fast enough than we can avoid, as a global society, hitting our global carrying capacity.

The second column comes from Brian Czech of the Center for the Advancement of the Steady State Economy and is in The Huffington Post. CASSE fundamentally believes that further growth in A is unsustainable because they believe that it will be impossible for Technology to keep up.  So, if the intensity of our economy will not continue to decrease, than even with a stable population, continued economic growth is unsustainable.  In this column, Dr. Czech makes the case that this fundamental truth is so powerful that environmentalists who have focused on climate change are making a grave error and should turn instead to a focus on limiting or eliminating economic growth.  This is the polar opposite view from Tim Harford, and encapsulates the pessimistic view on technology.

So, which of these views is the right one?  Ultimately I don't think we can know right now because the key factor, how quickly technology will move to increase our global carrying capacity, is unknowable.  There have been many civilizations for which Technology was not able to keep up with population and economic growth and which have disappeared (see Jared Diamond's Collapse), and these examples should concern us.  But, the larger history of human civilizations is more positive, and the literature is littered with dire predictions of the limits of human ingenuity and impending collapse (see The Limits to Growth arguments) that have not come true.

On the walls of Clarkson University's Concrete Cafe is my favorite quote, from the Roman engineer Julius Frontinus, speaking in the year 10 C.E., "Inventions have long since reached their limit, and I see no hope for further developments."  How many of us believe he was right?

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

On Measures of National Well-Being

Robert Costanza and colleagues have recently published a piece in Nature sounding the death-knell for GDP.  Arguing, again, that GDP is a bad measure of national "success" and pushing for the adoption of other measures to take its place, including the Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI).  There is little or nothing that is new in their criticisms of GDP, and I continue to be frustrated by the discussions.

As has been oft stated, no economist thinks that GDP is a measure of national "success".  It is often misconstrued as such, but I even think that the media is doing a better job of avoiding that mistake recently.  GDP measures the value of the production of marketed goods in an economy.  That's it.  It is only a measure of the economy.  The reason society wants, generally, this number to go up is that more or more valuable production means more money in the economy, no matter how it is distributed, and, generally, more income for individuals.  Costanza and company point to the following issues with GDP: 1) It does not account for degradation of natural resources and the environment;  2) It does not account for income inequality; 3) No accounting (or even positive accounting) for crime and other ills.

1)  This is true.  Depreciation of natural capital is generally not accounted for in GDP, and this does reflect a cost of production.  Many economists have argued strongly that this should be accounted for (see here), and on this point I am in agreement with Costanza et al.  Net National Product (NNP) or Net Domestic Product (NDP) account for depreciation of physical capital, and these are measured, like GDP, by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, but still do not include depreciation of natural capital.  But, it is not so much that we should include this as part of GDP, but that we should measure this depreciation, period, including it in GDP or not.  Of course, there are real challenges to measuring this depreciation and many of the same people who argue against GDP would also oppose the monetization of the environment.

2) President Obama has called income inequality the "defining challenge of our time."  There is little doubt that it is a major issue for a society and it can be measured in various ways, but not in such a way that it could be compared to GDP.  In other words, it is not clear that we can put dollar values on inequality because there is no accepted relationship between how inequality affects the economy or economic growth.  Nor is it clear how individuals or our society as a whole "values" inequality in the way we value goods or even the environment.

3)  GDP does not account for crime, but does account for expenditures on police services or security systems an other preventative measures. Of course, when crime is higher, this will negatively impact other economic activity, implying that it is not actually clear that more crime increases GDP.  But crime definitely affects "well-being" in a negative way, and this gets to what I think is the larger point in the debate about GDP.

What I think Costanza et al. really want is not so much a change in how we measure the economy or well-being, but a change in our societal priorities.  Their criticisms of GDP, I think, fall flat, but really they are critiquing societies apparent prioritization of economic growth over issues of inequality or crime or the environment.  But this is a much larger issue (or, actually, a SERIES of issues) and not something to be fixed by creating some aggregate and subjective measure of well-being like the Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) (which arbitrarily weights a number of societal factors in coming up with a single, blended measure).  I don't see that measuring GDP has caused us to prioritize economic growth.  Instead, we prioritize things like reducing unemployment and increasing standards of living which are usually correlated with economic growth.  Changing these priorities will take much more than adapting measures of well-being.


Tuesday, January 21, 2014

With a price on carbon, renewable portfolio standards are redundant, or worse

Robert Stavins is one of the preeminent environmental economists.  He recently posted a nice, short, piece about why eliminating redundant renewables targets in Europe would be a good thing, both economically and environmentally.  Here is the punchline:

----------------------------
If some emissions reductions are being achieved by the binding renewables policy, then there is less demand overall for tradable allowances. Since the supply of allowances has not changed, this means that allowance prices are inevitably suppressed; and low allowance prices mean less induced climate-friendly technological change over time.
---------------------------

One of the most attractive parts of carbon taxes, in particular, and to a less extent, cap and trade programs is the simplicity, if politicians would learn to keep their hands off of them.  The most recent real chance at a U.S. carbon policy was the Waxman-Markey bill.  When I teach it, late in the semester of my environmental economics class, after my students have heard chapter and verse on the advantages of incentive approaches (and some caveats too), I ask them, when looking through the list of what is included in the bill, "Why do we need a renewable portfolio standard?  Why do we need to mandate building efficiency improvement?"  We don't, is the point, once carbon in priced.  

Off-Topic #2: Jazz Albums: Ray Brown Trio - Live at Sculler's



This morning I put my collection of favorite Jazz tracks on shuffle and the second track to play was En Estate, performed by Ray Brown, with Benny Green and Gregory Hutchinson.  I can't find the track on youtube to link to it, but this got me listening to the whole album on which it appeared: Live at Scullers Jazz Club, from 1996/1997.

Ray Brown (who passed in 2002) was an incredibly prolific recording artist, mostly as the bass player in the Oscar Peterson Trio, but also on his own.  I have often found that late recordings by legendary artists can be disappointing, with some exceptions, but this is really a beautiful album that I highly recommend.  See this review for someone else's similar opinion and more detailed information on the album.